Rebirth
1. Why is the car crash so traumatic to David, and what does it symbolize?
David’s fear of becoming his father, or rather, likehis father, is constantly reiterated throughout Giovanni’s Room. After causing damage to another person because of his drunk driving, David realizes he is committing an action that is similar to what his father does, making the accident a moment that is traumatic to him. His father, an alcoholic, has verbally and [physically] abused David for much of his life, despite David not completely caring or realizing it. In landing himself and the other drivers in the hospital, David feels he is becoming like his father—hurting those around him because of his drinking and lack of prudence. The car accident is also traumatic as it is one of the first times David “meets” and calls for his mom. A figure who has never had a true presence in his life, only a photo in their house, and never talked about by David’s dad, David’s mother is an idealistic image of motherhood that David still relatively fears, as seen in his dream of her rotting corpse. This could show his fear of femininity, as he has trouble forming real connections to other females in his life. By seeing his mother for the first time, David is shocked by her presence and his brush with death, bringing him back to his search for identity while he is alive. Though David’s car accident is a source of trauma for David, it is also a symbol of self-realization and rebirth. After crashing into the other car, and landing in the hospital, David decides to move to France in search of himself. A car accident is something in which it is not uncommon for people die in. Though David lives, his past self has died and his new self, the one which desires to find his truth, is born, implying a motif of reincarnation and symbolizing rebirth.
Wow, Hannah - this is a phenomenal analysis! I really like how you brought up so many new ideas that I did not think about when I was reading - David's fear of femininity, for example. What I find most interesting here, though, is your relating David's possible physical death to his very real figurative death. It is easy to say that David left for France for a new beginning away from his father, but this analysis takes it to another level. I also liked how you touched on identity, which was the primary basis of my blog post. Thank you for enlightening me!
ReplyDeleteHannah,
ReplyDeleteI completely agree will of your points about the realities that David faces after his car accident, especially your argument that one of David's greatest fears was to end up similar to his father. Yet in his attempt to escape his emotions about his familial issues, he ends up showing similar problematic patterns of avoidance and falseness, and creates an outside persona to use as a barrier with the world. Also, I appreciated you analyzing his nightmares about his mother, as I had not considered the role that sexuality and femininity would play in this situation. Overall, great work! So excited to hear more from you, Hannah.
Bailey Meek
Hey Hannah! Whaddup Mr. Giddings. Okay back to Hannah. This post is a great analysis of the fever dream that plagues David after his drunk driving accident. I love how you expanded on the discussion we had in class last Thursday about how David's lack of a mother figure causes not only confusion around women in general (nothing like a fresh breath of misogyny in the morning), but also his almost idolatrous creation of a new mother. David's intense fear of becoming his father and hurting those around him comes true and spawns his split second decision to move to France, which in turn only intensifies as his time in France sees the execution of one friend, the failure of another relationship, and a scheming old man whose spirits' gone sour with old age. Good work today, Han, always a pleasure to read your work.
ReplyDelete